<- Back to Campus News
Professor's Essay Injects Controversy into Vaccination Debate
by Tina Weinheimer
Jenny McCarthy
In his newest essay for TheAtlantic.com, David M. Perry, associate professor of history, takes a firm but compassionate stance in challenging the claims of anti-vaccination proponents, including celebrity Jenny McCarthy.

As the father of a child with special needs, Perry discusses the dangers and risks presented by the anti-vaccination movement and the harm that Jenny McCarthy presents by putting “the full force of her celebrity to the task of convincing parents to leave their children vulnerable.”

Perry's Atlantic piece drew attention from other media outlets as well:
-Perry discussed the issue on KKSF-AM, a Clear Channel talk radio station in San Francisco (beginning at 3:08 mark).
David M. Perry, Dominican University-New York magazine's Daily Intelligencer blog referenced Perry's article.
-Business Insider included comments from Perry in a roundup of reaction's to ABC's announcement​.
-Bustle.com, a news and lifestyle blog, included Perry's comments in a piece on McCarthy's new position.
-Liberal commentary site Daily Kos also referenced Perry's writing in an opinion piece on the anti-vaccine movement.
-In addition, the original article was among top stories on social sharing sites Reddit and Flipboard and has been shared more than 15,000 times on social media channels.
McCarthy, whom ABC announced would join The View just days after Perry's article was published, claims that vaccinations caused her son’s ​autism and actively promotes this idea through the media. 

>>Perry followed up on his Atlantic essay with a piece for CNN Opinions on July 17. Click here to read that article​.

“Anti-vaccinators risk not only the lives of their own children, but also those of others who are too medically fragile to get vaccinated and must instead rely on “herd immunity," Perry writes. “Many medical conditions, especially those which compromise the immune system (which is fairly common in the world of Down syndrome), make vaccines medically inappropriate. Happ​ily, in a population of vaccinated people, infectious but preventable diseases have trouble spreading even to the immunocompromised. But herd immunity breaks down when vaccinations are not administered to all who can medically receive them. At that point, people who chose to refuse vaccinations endanger those who had no choice.”

In his essay, Perry cites the resurgence of many dangerous, but preventable diseases such as whooping cough, measles and mumps, along with data illustrating the increase in deaths internationally from the diseases. He also reminds readers that the anti-vaccination movement stems largely from a study based on fraudulent research, which was published in 1998. 

The article was later retracted by the medical journal when the data manipulation was discovered and multiple larger trials refuted the study’s conclusion. The researcher’s medical license was subsequently revoked.

Perry writes, “People with autism need support in their quest for self-advocacy and integration, not fads. Parents need communities and schools and scientifically guided medical care that they can rely on, not to be bilked by fraudsters and fear mongers. People with autism are not victims, and they do not need McCarthy's organization to "rescue" them. What they need is the same thing all persons with disability need: a pathway to inclusion.”

Click here to read the full essay on TheAtlantic.com.​
Contact: Jessica Mackinnon - (708) 524-6289 - jmack@dom.edu
More Dominican News
Halloween May be Scary but the Flu is Worse!
Last Flu Vaccine Clinic 10/29/2014 Parmer Hall 1-3 p.m. Cost $30  Read more...
Trick or Treat Halloween Open House Nursing Simulation Lab
Trick or Treat Halloween Open House 3-6 p.m. Wednesday, October 29, in the Nursing Simulation Lab.  Read more...
Claire Noonan quoted in Chronicle of Higher Education
Vice President of Mission and Ministry Claire Noonan is quoted in a Chronicle of Higher Education article on how Catholic colleges are promoting their mission.  Read more...
Open Call Auditions for Black Box Experiment
All students, faculty and staff are welcome to participate in the Open Call Auditions for the Black Box Experiment: Family.  Read more...
Cyber Security - Encryption

For week three of National Cyber Security Awareness Month, review encryption practices for web and file security.

 Read more...
The Mazzuchelli Lecture
Save the Date: November 5, Mazzuchelli Lecture "Caritas et Veritas: The Case for Cultural Competence." Read more...
Know Your Rights Workshop with the ACLU
Learn what your rights are if stopped or approached by police or immigration officers in this interactive workshop with legal experts.  Read more...
Dominican A-Z